Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Edit
ANOTHER VIEW THE (MINNEAPOLIS) STAR TRIBUNE

Editorial: Biden, Trump both mishandled classified materials

  • 0
The Robert F. Kennedy Justice Department Building

The Robert F. Kennedy Justice Department Building on Pennsylvania Avenue in Washington, D.C.

President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump are both being investigated over their handling of classified materials. While publicly disclosed information reflects that the cases are clearly different, the investigatory processes should not be.

To that end, Attorney General Merrick Garland rightly appointed special prosecutors in each instance, including naming Robert Hur — a Trump appointee — in the Biden case, just weeks after naming Jack Smith to lead the Trump investigation.

Each special prosecutor should uphold the ethos that justice is blind and follow the facts and the law in each case, without fear or favor and without bowing to the toxic political environment enveloping America.

In that other court — the one of public opinion — citizens should also follow the facts as reported and realize there are key distinctions between the two cases.

First, while the law is clear on the protocol on handling — or in Biden’s and Trump’s case, mishandling — classified material, the scale and scope of the documents discovered so far differ. More than 300 documents have surfaced in the Trump case, compared with about 10 in the initial discovery regarding Biden. However, further discoveries of classified documents held by Biden attests to the need for a thorough search process.

Biden’s attorneys were forthcoming about their initial discovery, which was reported to the National Archives on the same day. Trump’s tranche of documents, conversely, were the subject of repeated requests and an eventual subpoena, eventually resulting in the FBI being compelled to search his Mar-a-Lago residence.

“When is the FBI going to raid the many houses of Joe Biden, perhaps even the White House?” Trump wrote on his own social media network, Truth Social, echoing congressional calls from some Republicans for commensurate action. The answer, as lawmakers and the former president certainly know, is that there’s no evidence yet that a similar search is needed. Biden and his aides have been forthcoming and allowed full and unfettered access to possible areas where other documents could possibly be found, something Trump and his aides clearly did not do.

This isn’t the “weaponization” of the federal government against conservatives, as the newly empowered House GOP majority increasingly terms it, but appropriate protocol from an apolitical law enforcement agency — one that previous Republican politicians were right to support.

At this point, there are more questions than answers. For example, does a former president have the same responsibility for classified document handling as a former vice president? And what about the timing of the discoveries? Biden’s lawyers discovered the documents on Nov. 2, 2022, and the National Archives retrieved them the next day, then referred the matter to the Justice Department on Nov. 4. On Nov. 10, the Justice Department informed the White House it had begun a preliminary inquiry into the matter.

It’s fair and appropriate to ask why the Justice Department did not reveal its inquiry before Americans headed to the polls on Nov. 8, especially since Trump’s handling of classified documents had been a campaign issue for Biden and Democratic congressional candidates.

As these and other key questions are investigated, the news media must balance the gravity of the Biden findings in light of the Trump investigation. To date most major newspapers, as well as broadcast outlets such as CBS, which broke the story — have appropriately given it significant play. But part of the news media’s role includes context. And ultimately, as with all jurisprudence, the facts are what matter if justice indeed is to remain blind.

0 Comments
* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Defense spending is vital to the ensure the nation’s security. But that doesn’t mean the Pentagon should be above budget scrutiny. Far from it, as a recent audit reveals. Last week, the Government Accountability Office concluded that the Pentagon cannot account for at least $220 billion in military gear given out to defense contractors. Nor is this a new phenomenon. The report found that the ...

It may seem hard to believe, but there remains a hard-core group of partisans who still insist that a presidential election was stolen and that the victor is “illegitimate.” Perhaps these conspiracy theorists will finally reconsider in the wake of a new study by New York University which concludes that Russian tweets did little to increase Donald Trump’s vote count in the 2016 presidential ...

If President Joe Biden has a coherent strategy for ending the Ukraine war, now would be an opportune time to deploy it. On Wednesday, Biden announced that the U.S. will provide Ukraine with 31 M1A1 Abrams tanks. That’s the U.S.’ main battle tank, which our country has used for four decades. In tandem with Biden’s decision, Germany and other European allies will provide tanks. Politico reported ...

The Virginia General Assembly made history two years ago when it voted to legalize personal cultivation of marijuana and possession of the plant in small amounts, becoming the first state in the South to do so. Unfortunately, the legislation only went halfway. While lawmakers removed criminal punishment for recreational cannabis use, they did not take the necessary steps to establish a ...

The deadly toll of drug overdoses in Virginia just keeps getting worse. It will take a concerted statewide effort at every level — from leaders in Richmond to frontline workers across the state — to reduce the tragic numbers and make 2023 the year that deadly tide starts to turn. The numbers were still climbing in 2021 even though the increase in drug overdose deaths was not as dramatic as the ...

There is a 0% chance that a proposal to eliminate the federal income tax and replace it with a massive national sales tax will even get out of the Republican-controlled House, let alone become law. But the fact that such a bluntly soak-the-poor idea is even getting an airing under new House Speaker Kevin McCarthy should stand as ominous confirmation that he is basically a hostage to his ...

The start of a new year offers the perfect opportunity to better protect yourself, your financial health and your long-term future by resolving to take online security seriously in 2023. As crimes such as identity theft, fraud and scams proliferate in frequency and grow annually in severity, there is no better time to address this threat and adopt some tried-and-true best practices to guard ...

Virginia Attorney General Jason Miyares made a big show of announcing last year that his office had organized an Election Integrity Unit to bring more transparency and accountability to Virginia’s elections. But when asked for documents about the unit — in the interest of transparency and accountability — the AG’s office wanted to charge the Virginia NAACP nearly $20,000 to see them. The group ...

Whether President Joe Biden’s misguided plan to forgive some $400 billion in federal student-loan debt goes forward will ultimately be up to the Supreme Court. For now, there’s more the federal government should be doing to rein in the costs of higher education — and thus reduce how much students borrow in the first place. In particular: It should insist that colleges stop hiding exactly how ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.

Topics

Breaking News

News Alert