Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.

Editorial: The Virginia Supreme Court is a model of impartiality

  • 0
Virginia Supreme Court

The Virginia Supreme Court building in Richmond

The Supreme Court of Virginia has done the commonwealth’s citizens a favor. Recently, two court rulings made public access to court hearings and government employee information easier to obtain.

One decision barred the state from closing documents to the press and the public concerning an incident in Newport News when a former city police officer shot and killed a man. The court, in reversing a circuit court ruling, stated that, “In the context of criminal proceedings, the doctrine imposes a presumption of transparency on one of the most basic functions of government.”

The decision to unseal the documents was sent back to circuit court for arguments.

In the other case, the court ruled that the town of South Hill was wrong to withhold personnel information from the public that had been requested under the state’s Freedom of Information Act. The case involved employment disputes among the town’s staff.

There is a FOIA exemption in Virginia and four other states for “personal information,” and that phrase has been well-used and perhaps abused by some government officials. Anything that an employee does can be defined as “personal information,” but the Supreme Court has ruled that there are limits. The court stated that “data, facts and statements are private if their disclosure would constitute an ‘unwarranted invitation of personal privacy’ to a reasonable person under the circumstances.”

Government, on any level, should not be doing its business in the dark. That was the whole point of FOIA to begin with. It’s our business that’s being done, and we applaud the Supreme Court for making that more clear.

The state court has distinguished itself on at least one more occasion in the recent past.

In 2021, it showed itself to be refreshingly impartial when it appointed two Special Masters to redraw the state’s congressional and legislative districts after the legislature and a committee of politicians and other citizens were unable to do so. The Special Masters the court appointed did as fair a job as could have been done in weaning us off gerrymandering. Fears that the court would stack the deck by letting political bias ruin this once-in-a-decade chance to make the election process more fair proved baseless.

In an era when courts, including the highest one in the land, are suspected by some of having a political bias, the Supreme Court of Virginia sets a good example for solons everywhere.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

When Richie Neal was mayor of Springfield, in Western Massachusetts, in the 1980s, Donald Trump was a lying Manhattan real estate promoter who routinely cheated those who were foolish enough to do business with him. God knows what Trump’s tax returns looked like, but those suspect documents were a matter only between Trump and the IRS. Neal is now chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee ...

Just as it’s a good idea to child-proof a home before having toddlers over for a birthday party, congressional Democrats should be doing what they can during the current lame-duck session to prepare for the incoming Republican House majority — a crowd that has literally announced its intention to threaten America’s fiscal stability, block election reforms and abandon Ukraine. The current Democratic majority, working with whatever responsible Republicans they can get on board, can extremist-proof Congress in some important ways between now and January.

The shortage of doctors in Virginia and across the country is a serious health-care problem that is only going to get worse without strong, concerted action. The shortage is not just looming in the future. It is with us now, as many who have tried lately to get an appointment with a general practitioner or specialist can tell you. The long wait times can mean that a patient’s illness or injury ...

A top Russian oligarch and ally of Vladimir Putin openly stated that his country has engaged in U.S. election meddling and would continue doing so in future elections. That’s not exactly news, even if it’s the first such admission by someone so close to Putin. But the methods of meddling are what merit more congressional scrutiny because a gaping hole for exploitation remains in the U.S. election system: dark campaign money.

Groomers, they shout. Freaks. Pedophiles. The names and slurs are familiar. Their intent? To demean and belittle, to intimidate and threaten. The implications are unmistakable: People who identify as LGBTQ aren’t entitled to share the same spaces as other Americans. They don’t deserve the same legal protections. They shouldn’t exist. Far from being at the margins of our national political ...

For a six-month period last year, something life-changing happened for tens of millions of American families: They started receiving automatic monthly payments of as much as $300 per child to use for whatever they needed. But Congress allowed the payments to expire in January, ending an expanded child tax credit that slashed child poverty and could have been a source of financial stability as ...

It’s time for the federal Environmental Protection Agency to get tough about cleaning up the Chesapeake Bay. Much of the talk at the recent annual meeting of the Chesapeake Bay Program’s executive council was self-congratulatory praise of the progress that’s been made in saving the bay from being choked to death by pollution. The real story, though, is how much remains to be done, and the ...

Politicians often hold their noses to cut deals with people they wouldn’t normally speak with in order to advance their agenda, or their own political futures. The question each politician must ask is: How much nose-holding can I tolerate before I have to open a window and catch a breath of fresh air?

It may be a bit late in the game, but the Biden administration could benefit by creating a new Cabinet position: The Secretary of Thinking Things Through. If the president had such an adviser, the White House wouldn’t be in the position it is now, informing those applying for student loan debt relief with the web site message: “At this time, we are not accepting applications.” That sotto voce ...

NASA’s Artemis program is edging toward a return to the moon — this time to stay — with its successful launch this week of an uncrewed rocket. Some Americans looking at the Earth-bound problems all around us might reasonably ask: Why? The answer is not just about the scientific discovery that a permanent presence on the moon promises but also the much-needed sense of national purpose it could ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert